Posted in theology

Does God Ordain Tragedies? A Biblical Look at God’s Sovereignty

By Elizabeth Prata

EPrata photo

Last week there was an unfortunate incident last week where a Lear jet carrying 7 passengers and 2 pilots nosedived at a high rate of speed into the ground in Palm Beach, FL. I’d written:

While the Lord saw fit to call those 9 on board to their eternal destination, He also saw fit to preserve the person in the white car. None of the 9 on board knew that it was their last hour on earth. Be ready to meet God at any time, repent of sin and believe in Jesus as Savior.

My Twitter/X account is curated by me to have mainly Christians, and nice ones at that. Yet the incident was so talked-about that a lot of other people following not me, but the topic, commented on the post above. Many were sympathetic to my point, but others, including people who profess Christianity, were not.

The main complaint I received was that “God doesn’t kill anyone”, they claimed. Or they would say ‘The Bible says satan comes to kill’. Some objected to my use of the word ‘repent’, saying that it’s a man-made work and not part of salvation. Others just said things along these lines: “Utter lunacy”. As for that last comment, on Twitter I expect that kind of remark or reaction. It’s rough on that platform.

Then I posted it on Facebook. Surprisingly, I received the same kind of comments. Persistently.

If we approach this difficult topic with a Christian worldview, using the Bible, we can ask, Does God cause disasters and tragedies? As Ken Ham explains at Answers in Genesis,

First of all, we need to understand that we live in a fallen world that is “groaning” (Romans 8:22) because of the consequence of our sin in Adam, and God’s resulting judgments (Genesis 3). So it’s important to realize that earthquakes, hurricanes, tornadoes, floods, etc., are a result of God’s judgment—God’s judgment on our sin. And such will continue while this present earth remains.

Ultimately all the ‘bad’ that happens on this earth is caused by sin. God did not create sin and He doesn’t tempt anyone to sin. (James 1:13). In Him is no darkness at all. (1 John 1:5).

God ordains all things to happen. He ordains cancer, kidnapping, hurricanes, Lear jet crashes. Nothing happens by accident and nothing happens that surprises God. Here is Dave Mathis, using Calvin’s explanation as the example. Proximate means near:

It is interesting that Calvin does use cause, referring to God’s agency in bringing evil about, when he distinguishes between God as the “remote cause” and human agency as the “proximate cause.” Arguing that God is not the “author of sin,” he says, “the proximate cause is one thing, the remote cause another.” Calvin points out that when wicked men steal Job’s goods, Job recognizes that “The LORD gave and the LORD has taken away; may the name of the LORD be praised.” The thieves, proximate cause of the evil, are guilty; but Job doesn’t question the motives of the Lord, the remote cause.

God is sovereign over all: including life and death

Yet God is completely sovereign over ALL that happens in the universe. Jesus sustains it all with His word. (Hebrews 1:3). Not one molecule moves without His say-so.

Dave Mathis said “It is [God] who created, preserves, actuates and directs all things.“

In fact, God Himself stated in Isaiah 45:7in whatever translation you use, that He creates disaster/calamity

“The One forming light and creating darkness, Causing well-being and creating disaster; I am the LORD who does all these things.”

RC Sproul famously taught, “If there is one maverick molecule in the universe, one molecule running loose outside the scope of God’s sovereign ordination, then ladies and gentlemen, there is not the slightest confidence that you can have that any promise that God has ever made about the future will come to pass.“

God controls and decides who will live and who He will call to their eternal place

Does God directly kill people?

Yes. The Bible clearly shows that God directly kills masses of people and He kills them individually. He flooded the earth and killed all that dwell upon it except the 8 in the ark. He used armies to kill populations of whole cities such as Sodom, Gomorrah, Admah, & Zeboiim, and that included women and children and cattle.

He also directly struck down individuals. He killed Uzzah for touching the ark. Uzzah thought his hand was cleaner than the dirt on the ground. He killed Lot’s wife by turning her into a pillar of salt.

But Er, Judah’s firstborn, was evil in the sight of the LORD, so the LORD took his life. (Genesis 38:7).

Nadab and Abihu were killed for offering strange fire before the presence of the LORD. (Leviticus 10:1-2).

In case someone wants to state that those were done by the ‘Old Testament God’ who is meaner and more wrathful, where the New Testament Jesus is ‘nicer’, this is error. God is the same.

He struck down Ananias and Sapphira for lying to the Holy Spirit. (Acts 5:5,10).

Jesus promised to personally kill the false prophetess Jezebel in Revelation 2 if the church did not repent of following her-

And I will kill her children with plague, and all the churches will know that I am He who searches the minds and hearts; and I will give to each one of you according to your deeds. (Revelation 2:23).

Did God not crush His own Son? Lawless men colluded to put Jesus on the cross and they were the ones who actually drove the nails in, but this was due to God’s deliberate plan to sacrifice His own Son. God poured out His wrath on Jesus too.

this Man, delivered over by the predetermined plan and foreknowledge of God, you nailed to a cross by the hands of godless men and put Him to death. (Acts 2:23)

EPrata photo

Understand who God IS

When we hear people say that God is too nice to kill anyone, or that He just lets things just happen, or that satan is the sole cause of calamity…we must understand that God is high and transcendent. His ways are not our ways. We CANNOT use our finite view of ‘fairness’ or ‘justice’ to assess His deeds and motives. God is GOOD. He is HOLY. He is not us.

Ken Ham at AIG again

Then when Job wanted to defend himself before God, in Job 38–41, God asked Job many questions to help him realize he knows nothing compared to God. And Job responded, “I know that you can do all things, and that no purpose of yours can be thwarted. ‘Who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?’ Therefore I have uttered what I did not understand, things too wonderful for me, which I did not know. ‘Hear, and I will speak; I will question you, and you make it known to me.’ I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you; therefore I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes” (Job 42:2–6).

Job recognized he had to let God be God and realized we can’t understand the ways of God. We’re just finite, fallible people. And we deserve nothing! We don’t even deserve to exist. But God loves us so much he provided a gift of salvation through what his Son did for us on the cross. Wow! We owe him everything! And while we live on this earth, we cannot live above the curse.

God uses the sins of man and the cursed world to bring about good, to bring about judgment, and to demonstrate His sovereignty. In my opinion, the best explanation is when Joseph told his brothers in Genesis 50:20, that though they meant evil in trying to kill him… God MEANT it for good.

As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good in order to bring about this present result, to keep many people alive.

Gill’s Exposition explains the Genesis verse, “but God meant it unto good; he designed good should come by it, and he brought good out of it: this shows that this action, which was sinful in itself, fell under the decree of God“

He could have stopped Joseph’s brothers from throwing Joseph into the pit. He could have cause the chief cupbearer to remember Joseph to Pharaoh. But He did not.

Joseph’s brothers had an evil intent. We understand this because we are human, like them. But the verse says God MEANT it.

Sinful men sin. We are all sinners who, as Ken Ham said, we do not deserve even to live. But God uses, ordains, or causes all things to happen to bring about His good plans and purposes.

Further Reading

God meant it for good, Ligonier short article

Does God create calamity? Ken Ham article at Answers in Genesis

No Maverick Molecule, Ligonier devotional

Does God ’cause’ sin? Dave Mathis at Desiring God article

Does GOD actively plan for us to sin? John MacArthur, 1:52 video

Why Does God Allow Pain and Suffering? Sproul video, 4 min

Posted in encouragement, I am, satan

I AM vs. I will

By Elizabeth Prata

Jesus said I AM seven times. Satan said “I will” five times. There is a big difference between I AM and I will.

Jesus said,

  • “I am the bread of life. (John 6:35).
  • “I am the light of the world. (John 8:12).
  • “I am the door. (John 10:9).
  • “I am the good shepherd. (John 11:25).
  • “I am the way, the truth, and the life. (John 14:6).
  • “I am the true vine, and My Father is the vinedresser” (John 15:1).

In Isaiah 14:14-15 it is said of Lucifer,

How art thou fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning! how art thou cut down to the ground, which didst weaken the nations! For thou hast said in thine heart,

  • I will ascend into heaven, 
  • I will exalt my throne above the stars of God: 
  • I will sit also upon the mount of the congregation, in the sides of the north:
  • I will ascend above the heights of the clouds; 
  • I will be like the most High.

Yet thou shalt be brought down to hell, to the sides of the pit. (Isaiah 14:14-15)

Jesus declared himself I AM out loud, before many, Satan said quietly in his heart. Jesus declares the reality, Satan declares his individual desire. Jesus is eternally I AM, satan was created and generated ambition later.

Jesus was, and is, and is to come (Revelation 1:8) and what He purposes will come to pass (Isaiah 46:10. Satan WILL NEVER, EVER, EVER HAVE ANY OF HIS WISHES, HOPES, AMBITIONS, GOALS, OR PURPOSES ULTIMATELY COME TO PASS. (Revelation 20:10).

Jesus did it all, He paid it all, it is finished.

Friends, remember, satan is a defeated foe. He is active, but moot. He is around, but vanquished. Those of us in Christ are victorious through Christ’s eternal act of submission, crucifixion, and resurrection, His love, and His will.

Satan says he will, but GOD DID.

 

Posted in theology

Lessons from Elihu: Listening and Wisdom in Job

By Elizabeth Prata

SYNOPSIS

The post discusses Elihu’s perspective in the Book of Job, emphasizing his respectful listening and patience despite being younger than Job’s friends. Elihu criticizes Job’s self-justification and highlights that suffering may serve purposes beyond punishment for sin, as the other 3 friends insisted. Ultimately, Elihu encourages trust in God.

Continue reading “Lessons from Elihu: Listening and Wisdom in Job” →
Posted in theology

Prata Potpourri: Election reflections, Helpful new info on Steve Lawson, Owen Strachan’s great essay

By Elizabeth Prata

We are so undeserving of this reprieve. I am feeling extremely grateful. But let us make the most of it while we can. Below is what I posted on my social media today-


I am still mulling over the Steve Lawson situation. He is the man who was world renowned for expository preaching, a traveling teacher at Trinity Baptist Church, Ligonier, The Master’s Seminary, and Grace Community Church, in addition to his own ministry he founded, OnePassion. He engaged in a 5-year adulterous affair with a woman almost 50 years younger than himself, was outed by Trinity Church, fired, and subsequently Lawson hasn’t been seen or heard from since. The other ministries such as Ligonier and TMS etc fired him and OnePassion’s Expositor Magazine folded.

It was a shock.

There were a lot of hot takes, a lot of discussion, and there is even now, two months later, lingering chats about the fall of a once-seemingly solid Christian. Of the media I consumed about this issue, this one from With All Wisdom (WaW) was the most measured, informative, and gracious I have heard or read. They waited over 5 weeks to comment, and did much first-hand investigation and interviews to learn more.

One thing they discussed was Lawson’s preference for expensive things- ties, suits, hotels, food etc. They mentioned his salary and honoraria, and the tax returns. I took a look after the podcast ended to see myself and saw that according to the IRS 990 form for OnePassion, Anne Lawson, Steve’s wife, states that she worked for the ministry 1 hour per week and earned a $30,000 salary.

Interestingly, the With All Wisdom guys learned that Lawson was not listed as nor described as a pastor at Trinity Baptist, not an elder, and not even a member. He was listed in their leadership page as “Lead Preacher”. When Trinity Bible Church was asked by With All Wisdom if the church would go forward with church discipline, the church said no. They can’t. Lawson wasn’t a pastor nor a church member. Lawson was accountable to no one, and as the guys on the podcast said, this is errant ecclesiology and in all likelihood even led to the circumstances that allowed the scandal to erupt.

Interestingly though, the OnePassion IRS tax return lists Lawson as “a teaching pastor”. In my opinion, he and/or the church are playing with semantics. Because Lawson was not a pastor in any sense of the word. He was an itinerant teacher, trotting the globe (while living a shameful double life).

Based on the With All Wisdom podcast’s information, I now know why Trinity Bible Church isn’t issuing any further information. I will also stop looking for it.

Tune into With All Wisdom’s chat to hear wisdom and grace over the situation. For me, their teaching on lessons learned was invaluable. For example, the difference between ‘wrong information’ and ‘wrong impressions’ was a lesson I took to heart.


I like Owen Strachan’s writing. Strachan (pronounced Strachan, rhymes with ran) published an essay yesterday titled Morning in America Again: 7 Reflections from Trump’s Election. If you are of an age like I am, you remember the highly evocative and effective re-election campaign by Ronald Reagan called Morning in America.

“The Spirit of the Abyss” by Wilhelm Kotarbinski

Strachan’s thoughts essentially mirrored mine above but of course fleshed out and better. I think a lot of people are thinking along these lines:

We have all lived through a long and almost unbroken nightmare. We have been forced to contemplate not only our present darkness, but the possibility of still greater unleashing of darkness through the presidency of Kamala Harris. We have trembled at that reality; we have wept; we have felt great surging waves of fear, anxiety, doubt, discouragement, and hopelessness at times.

“We have all lived through a long and almost unbroken nightmare. We have been forced to contemplate not only our present darkness, but the possibility of still greater unleashing of darkness through the presidency of Kamala Harris. We have trembled at that reality; we have wept; we have felt great surging waves of fear, anxiety, doubt, discouragement, and hopelessness at times. But for now, we have been granted a reprieve, a temporary stalling of evil as driven by the modern political left.”

Strachan is Senior Director of the Dobson Culture Center and Host of Grace & Truth podcast. His essay was poignant about the election but also a call to arms, with a warning not to rest. But so encouraging to think, as he postulated, that woke ideology is waning, that the near future might actually have a positive effect on gender wars, that legacy reporting institutions are mostly dead… do read his wonderful essay!


And now we return to a world absent of glossy political fliers in the mail, our phones will calm down from incessant political ads, and hopefully our Bibles will be opened more frequently as we have stared into a world where fascism and oligarchy, not to mention Banana Republic, was looming over us like the Great Wave at Kanagawa. May we give proper glory to God for His kindness.

Posted in discernment, Uncategorized

If Jeremiah, John the Baptist, and Paul were Arminian…

Today’s essay explores the notion that if Jeremiah, John the Baptist, and Paul had been Arminians, how would their testimonies sound? Using today’s vernacular, let’s see how it reads when these eminent Christians say they “chose God” of their own free will.

——————————————–

Photo from Pixabay.com

The Sovereign call of Jeremiah to speak YHWH’s words becomes:
Jeremiah asking Jesus into His heart and making a career decision,

“When I was a youth, one night I couldn’t sleep. I walked around for a while outside, unfamiliar with this restless feeling. I felt young and inept at whatever I tried my hand. I remember clearly, it was the third of Tishrei, a cool September morning. I was at Sabbath at the synagogue. I was overcome with Avital’s lyre playing of the ninth repetition of “Just As I Am.” It all came together in my heart. I made a decision to walk the aisle toward the rabbi, and I knelt down and sincerely asked Messiah into my heart. Rabbi told me I was saved. Afer that, I decided I wanted to be a Prophet of God because I knew that God had a great plan for my life. When I came forward the priest had told me that. I became a prophet even though I was young and didn’t know how to speak. It was a God thing for sure. I’m so happy that day I walked the aisle and decided for the Savior.”

The powerful testimony of Christian Terrorist Paul on the road to Damascus becomes:
Paul meekly being led in praying the Sinner’s Prayer and choosing to change his whole life around-

Paul explained, “I was exceeding my peers in Law, at that time I was breathing out threats and fire against the Christians. I was at the peak of my career. I had the esteem of my colleagues, and I was young enough to have the world in front of me. Yet something lacked. Then one day while I was walking along the road to Damascus on an official Pharisaical mission to jail and execute followers of The Way, I felt a restlessness. Is this all there is, I wondered? Just being the best at everything and killing blasphemers, nice as that was? I spoke about it with the men who were walking with me, but most of them didn’t understand, except for one fellow traveler. He explained that I needed to decide to follow Jesus and that I should use my free will to choose Him. Of course! That was the answer. He led me in the sinner’s prayer. I’ve been saved ever since. You should decide for Jesus too, everyone should. I don’t know why they don’t. That I did is what makes me a great example of Christian self-decisional regeneration. Not to boast, though. Grace and peace to you.”

John the Baptist’s call as the last Old Testament Prophet, foreordained and empowered since the womb, becomes a lifestyle choice-
John the Baptist shares his testimony about accepting Jesus

“I didn’t get along with my parents, they were very aged and they just didn’t understand me or my generation. I felt so lonely, like I didn’t fit in with any of my friends. I went to live in the desert to try and find myself, and figure it all out. One day as I was roasting some locusts over the fire and sewing a new camel hair outfit, I realized suddenly that what I needed was Messiah. What I lacked was that I hadn’t accepted Jesus as my personal Lord and Savior! I decided to give my heart to Jesus. I also decided to stay in the desert. It’s a relationship, not a religion, so who needs church? I have peace about that.”

Don’t those Arminian testimonies sound ridiculous? We do not decide for Jesus. He decided long before the world was ever made or we were ever born. Now here is how it really happened, with the addition of the verses about God’s call to Jesus to become His Son.

The Call of Jeremiah-

Now the word of the LORD came to me, saying,
“Before I formed you in the womb I knew you,
and before you were born I consecrated you;
I appointed you a prophet to the nations
.”
(Jeremiah 1:4-5)

Paul-

But when God, who set me apart from my mother’s womb and called me by His grace, was pleased to reveal His Son in me so that I might preach Him among the Gentiles,
(Galatians 1:15-16)

John the Baptist-

for he will be great in the sight of the Lord. He shall never take wine or strong drink, and he will be filled with the Holy Spirit even from his mother’s womb. (Luke 1:15).

Jesus-

I will tell of the decree: The LORD said to me, “You are my Son; today I have begotten you”. (Psalm 2:7)

And now says the LORD, who formed Me from the womb to be His Servant, To bring Jacob back to Him, so that Israel might be gathered to Him (For I am honored in the sight of the LORD, And My God is My strength), (Isaiah 49:5).

I am not familiar with this author but I thought his explanation of the biblical truth of God’s sovereign choice of His elect was the clearest and most succinct I’ve read in a while.

Why is one’s understanding of election important?

Why is it important to understand that election is unconditional and individual? If we believe, as Arminians propose, that election is the result of God looking ahead via His omniscient foreknowledge to see who will choose Him and persevere in Him, we make God’s choice of particular people contingent upon their choice/faith in Him. This makes election a reward or an obligation that is given in response to foreseen faith. This is not the gospel of grace. Election in this view is not God independently choosing us; rather, we are choosing Him and He is merely ratifying the choice by calling “elect” those who have chosen Him. Again, this makes man, not God, sovereign in election, and dishonors God by diminishing His sovereignty. 

Such a view also leaves a pocket for pride in the human heart. Since the choice to believe is supposedly made by the sinner independently, the one who chooses to believe and respond positively to the gospel offer has proven himself more “worthy” of salvation, with all its attendant blessings, than the one who rejects the gospel. Of course, such an exalted view of man is unjustified by Scripture.  

We do not choose Jesus. If we did, we could – and would – boast. No, He chooses us. All the glory rightly belongs to Him.